Mr.
Michael West reports
CE FRANKLIN LTD. ANNOUNCES 2011 FOURTH QUARTER RESULTS
CE Franklin Ltd. has released financial results, including net earnings of $4.5-million or 26 cents per share (basic), for the
fourth quarter ended Dec. 31, 2011, a significant increase from net
earnings of $1.6-million or nine cents per share (basic) generated in the
fourth quarter ended Dec. 31, 2010. For 2011, net income was $14.3-million or 82 cents per share (basic), an increase of 142 per cent from the $5.9-million or 34 cents per share (basic) earned in 2010.
"Strong year-over-year revenue growth, improved product margins and
disciplined cost management led to significant year-over-year
improvement in the fourth quarter. We will continue to leverage our
strategies into 2012," said Michael West, president and chief executive officer.
The Dec. 31, 2011, condensed interim consolidated financial
statements are prepared under international financial reporting
standards. Consequently the comparative figures for 2010 and
the company's statement of financial position as at Jan. 1, 2010,
have been restated from accounting principles generally accepted in
Canada to comply with IFRS. The reconciliations from
the previously published Canadian generally accepted accounting principles financial statements are
summarized in Note 3 to the condensed interim consolidated financial
statements, and there were no material differences.
Net earnings for the fourth quarter of 2011 were $4.5-million, an
increase of $2.9-million from the fourth quarter of 2010. Revenues for
the fourth quarter of 2011 were $154.3-million, an increase of $18.7-million (14 per cent) from the fourth quarter of 2010. Well completions
decreased 9 per cent compared with the fourth quarter of 2010 as the fourth
quarter of 2010 was a busy quarter and those activity levels carried
into 2011, while the fourth quarter 2011 slowed down slightly due to
lower natural gas activity. Capital project business revenue grew $6.8-million year over year due to the improved overall industry activity
levels. Gross profits increased by $4.8-million (23 per cent) due to the
increase in revenues and improved gross profit margins year over year.
Average gross profit margins in the fourth quarter of 2011 were lower
than the third quarter of 2011 due to more pipe flange and fitting
sales to lower margin alliance customers. Average gross profit margins
for the fourth quarter of 2011 were higher than the fourth quarter 2010
as increased purchasing levels contributed to higher-volume rebates.
Sales, general and administrative expenses increased by $800,000 (5 per cent) to $17.5-million for the
quarter as compensation and operating costs have increased in response
to higher revenue levels. Fourth quarter earnings for 2010 included a
$700,000 after-tax charge associated with the elimination of the
stock option cash settlement mechanism. The company also recorded an
unrealized foreign exchange loss of $800,000 in the quarter on
foreign exchange contracts used to manage currency exposure on U.S.-denominated product purchases, which reversed a previously recognized
unrealized gain on these contracts in the third quarter. The weighted
average number of shares outstanding during the fourth quarter was
consistent with the prior-year period as the rise in share price during
the last year limited the activity occurring under the normal course
issuer bid program. Net earnings per share (basic) were 26 cents in the
fourth quarter of 2011, compared with net earnings of nine cents per share in
the fourth quarter of 2010.
Net income for the year ended Dec. 31, 2011, was $14.3-million, an
increase of $8.4-million (142 per cent) compared with 2010, as industry activity
levels improved year over year. Well completions in 2011 rose by 17 per cent
compared with 2010 as the industry was focused on oil, oil sands and
liquid-rich natural gas plays. Revenues increased by 12 per cent to $546.4-million, as both capital project and maintenance repair and operating
sales increased year over year. Gross profits increased by $15.7-million (21 per cent) due to the impact of higher sales and increased vendor
rebates from increased purchasing levels. Sales, general and administrative costs increased by
$6.2-million (9.8 per cent) to $68.7-million in 2011 as compensation costs and
operating costs have increased in response to higher activity levels.
Income tax expense increased by $1.9-million as a result of higher
pretax earnings in 2011. The weighted average number of shares
outstanding (basic) during 2011 was consistent with the prior year as
the rise in the share price during the last year has limited the
activity occurring under the normal course issuer bid program. Net
earnings per share (basic) were 82 cents in 2011, a 141-per-cent increase from
2010, consistent with the increase in net income.
Business outlook
CE Franklin's revenues are expected to increase modestly in 2012 as the
oil and gas industry activity levels remain relatively consistent with
2011 levels. Natural gas prices remain depressed as North American
production capacity and inventory levels continue to dominate demand.
Natural gas capital expenditure activity is focused on the emerging
shale gas plays in northeastern British Columbia and liquid-rich gas
plays in northwestern Alberta, where the company has a strong market
position. Conventional and heavy oil economics are attractive at
current price levels leading to increased activity in eastern Alberta
and southeast Saskatchewan. The company expects oil sands project announcements
will continue at current levels, assuming current oil price levels are
maintained. Approximately 50 per cent to 60 per cent of the company's total revenues
are driven by the company's customer capital expenditure requirements.
Gross profit margins are expected to remain under pressure as customers
that produce natural gas focus on reducing their costs to maintain
acceptable project economics and due to continued aggressive oil field
supply industry competition as industry activity levels remain below
the last five-year average. The company will continue to manage its
cost structure to protect profitability while maintaining service
capacity and advancing initiatives.
Over the medium to longer term, the company's strong financial and
competitive positions should enable profitable growth of its
distribution network through the expansion of its product lines,
supplier relationships, and capability to service additional oil and
gas and other industrial end use markets.
Business strategy
The Canadian oil field equipment supply industry is highly competitive
and fragmented. There are approximately 230 oil field supply stores in
Canada, which generate annual estimated sales of $2-billion to $3-billion. CE Franklin competes with three other large oil field product
distributors and with numerous local and regional distributors, as well
as specialty equipment distributors and manufacturers. The oil field
equipment market is part of the larger industrial equipment supply
market, which is also serviced by numerous competitors. The oil sands
and niche industrial product markets are more specialized and solutions
oriented and require more in-depth product knowledge and supplier
relationships to service specific customer requirements.
Oil field equipment distributors compete based on price and level of
service. Service includes the ability to provide required
products consistently to a customer's operating site when needed, project management
services, product expertise and support, billing and expenditure
management services, and related equipment services.
Demand for oil field products and services is driven by the level of
capital expenditures in the oil and gas industry in the Western
Canadian sedimentary basin, as well as by production-related
maintenance, repair and operating requirements. MRO demand
tends to be relatively stable over time and predictable in terms of
product and service requirements and typically comprises 40 per cent to 50 per cent of
the company's annual sales. Capital project demand fluctuates over
time with oil and gas commodity prices, which directly impact the
economic returns realized by oil and gas companies.
The size, scope and product mix of each order will affect
profitability. Local walk in relationship business with smaller orders
or more specialized products will typically generate higher profit
margins compared with large project bids for alliance customers, where the
company can take advantage of volume discounts and longer lead times.
Larger oil and gas customers tend to have a broader geographic
operating reach requiring multisite service capability, conducting
larger capital projects, and requiring more sophisticated billing and
project management services than do smaller customers. The company
has entered into a number of formal alliances with larger customers,
where the scale and repeat nature of business enable efficiencies,
which are shared with the customer through lower profit margins.
Barriers to entry in the oil field supply business are low with start-up
operations typically focused on servicing local relationship-based MRO
customers. To compete effectively on capital project business and to
service larger customers require multilocation branch operations,
increased financial, procurement, product expertise and breadth of
product lines, information systems, and process capability.
The company's 39-branch operations provide substantial geographic
coverage across the oil- and gas-producing regions in Western Canada.
Each branch services and competes for local business and services the
company's alliance customers supported by centralized support services
provided by the company's distribution centre and corporate office in
Calgary. The company's large branch network, coupled with its
centralized capabilities, enables it to develop strong supply chain
relationships with suppliers and provide it with a competitive
advantage over local independent oil field and specialty equipment
distributors for large alliance customers, which are seeking
multilocation, one-stop shopping and more comprehensive service. The
company's relationship with Wilson Supply, a leading oil field equipment
distributor operating in the United States, and a wholly owned
subsidiary of Schlumberger, enables it to provide North American
solutions to its customer base and provides increased purchasing scale
with equipment suppliers.
The company is pursuing the following strategies to build its business
profitably:
- Expand the reach and market share serviced by the company's distribution
network; the company is focusing its sales efforts and product
offering on servicing complex, multilocation needs of large and
emerging customers in the energy sector; organic growth may be
complemented by selected acquisitions;
- Expand production equipment service capability to capture more of the
product life cycle requirements for the equipment the company sells,
such as downhole pump repair, oil field engine maintenance, well
optimization and on-site project management; this will differentiate the
company's service offering from its competitors and deepen
relationships with its customers;
- Expand oil sands, industrial project and MRO business by leveraging the company's existing supply chain infrastructure, product and major project
expertise;
- Increase the resourcing of customer project sales quotation and order
fulfilment services provided by the company's distribution centre to augment
local branch capacity to address seasonal and project-driven
fluctuations in customer demand; by doing so, the company aims to increase its capacity flexibility and improve operating efficiency while providing
consistent customer service.
Strategy accomplishments
In the spring of 2008, the company moved into a new 153,000-square-foot
distribution centre and nine-acre pipe yard located in Edmonton,
Alta. The new distribution centre provided a 76-per-cent increase in
functional warehousing capacity over the company's previous facility, increasing
its capability to support and build sales through the company's branch network.
The larger facility also enabled the company to increase the company's central
project execution capability and processes and to service larger projects
and ship direct to customers, avoiding double handling of material by
branches.
In June of 2009, the company increased its market share, customer base
and branch network through the acquisition of a Western Canadian
oil field supply competitor. The acquired
business operated 23 supply stores of which 18 stores were proximate to
existing company branches and were integrated. The remaining five
operations were focused in the eastern Alberta heavy oil corridor and
have extended the company's distribution network reach. Total oil field
supply sales have increased an estimated 15 per cent as a result of the
acquisition. The company's Fort St. John and Lloydminster branches
moved to larger locations during the year, increasing capacity to
service customer requirements in these important markets. Sales to oil
sands customers increased for the fifth year in a row, reaching a
record $64.5-million in 2009, comprising 15 per cent of total company sales.
The company added process automation products to its product line and
opened a valve actuation centre at the company's Edmonton distribution centre to
broaden the spectrum of solutions the company provides to existing
oil field, oil sands and other industrial customers and enhance its
ability to attract new customers. The company recruited new product,
operations and supply chain expertise into the organization to advance
its strategies.
In 2011 and 2010, the company made advances in the central resourcing of
project work by processing $161.2-million (2010: $99.3-million) of
sales orders through the company's Edmonton distribution centre, representing 29 per cent
(2010: 20 per cent) of total company sales. This enabled the company to service the
12-per-cent year-over-year increase in sales (2010: 12-per-cent increase). In 2011 and
2010, the company has continued to build its valve actuation business.
Revenues
Revenues for the quarter ended Dec. 31, 2011, were $154.3-million,
an increase of 14 per cent from the quarter ended Dec. 31, 2010.
Oil and gas commodity prices are a key driver of industry capital
project activity as commodity prices directly impact the economic
returns realized by oil and gas companies. The company uses oil and gas
well completions and average rig counts as industry activity measures
to assess demand for oil field equipment used in capital projects. Oil
and gas well completions require the products sold by the company to
complete a well and bring production on stream and are a general
indicator of energy industry activity levels. Average drilling rig
counts are also used by management to assess industry activity levels
as the number of rigs in use ultimately drives well completion
requirements.
Revenues from capital project related products were $80.3-million in the
fourth quarter of 2011, an increase of 9 per cent ($6.8-million) from the
fourth quarter of 2010. Total well completions decreased by 9 per cent in the
fourth quarter of 2011, and the average working rig count increased by
23 per cent compared with the prior-year period. Gas wells comprised 23 per cent of the
total wells completed in Western Canada in the fourth quarter of 2011
compared with 45 per cent in the fourth quarter of 2010. Spot gas prices ended
the fourth quarter at $2.64 per gigajoule (AECO), a decrease of 18 per cent from
fourth quarter 2010 average prices. Oil prices ended the fourth
quarter at $103.61 per barrel (synthetic crude), an increase of 1 per cent from
the fourth quarter 2010 average. Depressed gas prices are expected to
continue to impact gas drilling activity negatively into 2012, which in
turn is expected to constrain demand for the company's products.
Natural gas customers continue to utilize a high level of competitive
bid activity to procure the products they require in an effort to
reduce their costs. The company is addressing this industry trend by
pursuing initiatives focused on improving revenue quotation processes
and increasing the operating flexibility and efficiency of its branch
network. The company is well positioned to support customers which are
pursuing oil plays and more particularly tight oil plays.
Revenues for capital-project-related products were $286.0-million for
the full year 2011, up $30.7-million (12 per cent) from 2010. The increase in
capital-project end use revenues reflects the 17-per-cent increase in total
industry well completions to 14,471 in 2011. Capital project business
for the year comprised 52 per cent of total revenues as it did in 2010. While
the capital project business represented the same percentage of the
business year over year, its makeup changed as a 19-per-cent decline in tubular
revenues was offset by a 4-per-cent increase in oil sands sales and increased
branch-based capital project sales. Tubular sales in the year declined
as the company followed a disciplined approach in its competitive bid
processes and, as a result, were not as successful as they had been in
prior years. There remains a significant amount of tubular product
inventory on hand in the industry, which has led to a very competitive
environment for tubular product sales.
MRO product revenues are related to overall oil and gas industry
production levels and tend to be more stable than capital project
revenues. MRO product revenues for the quarter ended Dec. 31, 2011,
increased by $11.9-million (19 per cent) to $74.0-million compared with the
quarter ended Dec. 31, 2010, and comprised 48 per cent of the company's
total revenues (2010: 46 per cent). MRO product revenues for the full year
2011 increased by $26.1-million (11 per cent) to $260.4-million compared with 2010 and comprised 48 per cent of the company's total revenues (2010: 48 per cent).
Higher MRO revenues in 2011 were due to increased conventional oil field
activity.
The company's strategy is to grow profitability by focusing on its core
Western Canadian oil field product distribution business, complemented
by an increase in the product life cycle services provided to its
customers and the focus on the emerging oil sands capital project and
MRO revenues opportunities.
Revenues from oil field products to conventional Western Canada oil and
gas end use applications were $132.4-million for the fourth quarter of
2011, an increase of 12 per cent from the fourth quarter 2010. This increase
was driven by an increase in oil well completions compared with the prior-year period.
Revenues from oil sands end use applications were $15.5-million in the
fourth quarter, an increase of $4.0-million (35 per cent) compared with $11.5-million in the fourth quarter of 2010 reflecting increased capital
project revenues, which were partially offset by the impact of not
having a large tailing line pipe order and having less turnaround work
in 2011 with the company's Fort McMurray-based customers.
Production service revenues were $6.4-million in the fourth quarter of
2011, a 7-per-cent increase from the $6.0-million of revenues in the fourth
quarter of 2010, reflecting improved oil production economics resulting
in increased customer maintenance activities.
Gross profit was $25.3-million in the fourth quarter of 2011, an
increase of $4.8-million (23 per cent) from the fourth quarter of 2010 due to
increased revenues and average gross profit margins compared with the
prior-year period. Gross profit margins for the quarter were lower than
the third quarter of 2011 due to more pipe, flange and fittings sales
to lower margin alliance customers. Average gross profit margins were
better than the prior-year period at 16.4 per cent as increased purchasing
levels contributed to higher-volume rebate income. Increased pipe,
flanges, fittings and pumps production equipment and services' gross
profit composition was due to improved gross profit margins.
Sales, general and administrative costs increased $800,000 (5 per cent) in the fourth quarter of 2011
from the prior-year period and represented 11 per cent of revenues compared with 12 per cent in the prior-year period. The $800,000 increase in expenses was
attributable to higher incentive and higher-agent-commission costs
reflecting the improved profit performance of the business year over
year.
Depreciation expense
Depreciation expense of $600,000 in the fourth quarter of 2011 was
comparable with the fourth quarter of 2010.
Interest expense
Interest expense of $100,000 in the fourth quarter of 2011 was lower
than the prior year due to lower borrowing levels.
Foreign exchange and other
Foreign exchange and other in the quarter were a loss of $1.1-million as
the Canadian dollar strengthened, which increased the translation loss
from U.S.-denominated net working capital assets. The company recognized
a $200,000 unrealized foreign currency gain on $18.3-million of
foreign currency forward contracts it had outstanding at quarter-end.
As at Dec. 31, 2011, a 1-per-cent change in the Canadian dollar
relative to the U.S. dollar would decrease or increase the company's
annual net income by approximately $200,000.
Income tax expense
The company's effective tax rate for the fourth quarter of 2011 was
24.4 per cent down from a 46.6-per-cent effective rate in the fourth quarter 2010. The
fourth quarter 2010 effective rate resulted from the write-off of $500,000 of future tax assets related to the removal of the cash
settlement mechanism from the company's stock option plan as a result
of provisions contained in the federal government's 2010 budget, which
effectively eliminated the ability to deduct for tax purposes cash
payments made to settle stock option obligations. The current
effective tax rate is lower than the statutory rate due to the impact
of non-deductible items and other adjustments. Substantially all of the
company's tax provision is currently payable.
CONDENSED INTERIM CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF EARNINGS AND COMPREHENSIVE INCOME
(in thousands of Canadian dollars except per share amounts)
Three months ended Twelve months ended
Dec. 31, Dec. 31, Dec. 31, Dec. 31,
2011 2010 2011 2010
Revenue $154,331 $135,641 $546,352 $489,585
Cost of sales 129,077 115,095 455,669 414,579
Gross profit 25,254 20,546 90,683 75,006
Other expenses
Selling, general and
administrative expenses 17,535 16,738 68,715 62,554
Depreciation 613 610 2,450 2,465
Total 18,148 17,348 71,165 65,019
Operating profit 7,106 3,198 19,518 9,987
Foreign exchange gain/(loss) and other 1,119 (20) (649) (65)
Interest expense 65 158 464 698
Earnings before tax 5,922 3,060 19,703 9,354
Income tax expense (recovery)
Current 1,862 979 6,245 3,102
Deferred (417) 448 (853) 341
Total 1,445 1,427 5,392 3,443
Net earnings and comprehensive income 4,477 1,633 14,311 5,911
Net earnings per share
Basic 0.26 0.09 0.82 0.34
Diluted 0.25 0.09 0.79 0.33
Conference call and webcast information
A conference call to review the fourth quarter 2011 results, which is
open to the public, will be held on Feb. 3, 2012, at 11 a.m. Eastern Time (9 a.m. Mountain Time).
Participants may join the call by dialling 1-647-427-7450 in Toronto or
dialling 1-888-231-8191 at the scheduled time of 11 a.m. Eastern
Time. For those unable to listen to the live conference call, a replay will
be available at approximately 2 p.m. Eastern Time on the same day by
calling 1-416-849-0833 in Toronto or dialling 1-855-859-2056 and entering the passcode of 42851162 and may be accessed until Feb. 9, 2012, at midnight.
The call will also be webcast and available on the company's website.
Michael West, president and chief executive officer, will lead the
discussion and will be accompanied by Derrren Newell, vice-president
and chief financial officer. The discussion will be followed by a
question-and-answer period.
We seek Safe Harbor.
© 2026 Canjex Publishing Ltd. All rights reserved.